spot_img

LATEST NEWS

Related Posts

WHO PROFITS WHEN YOUR DATA EXPIRES?

Lonestar, Orange and LTA Face Questions Over Millions of Liberians’ Unused Airtime, Internet Bundles and Consumer Rights

By Lyndon J. Ponnie, Sr., 

Liberian Investigative Journalist

 

MONROVIA, LIBERIA — Every day, thousands of Liberians spend their hard-earned money purchasing internet bundles, call credits and other telecommunications services. Students depend on mobile data for research, businesses use it to communicate with customers, traders rely on mobile money, and families use telephone services to stay connected.

But behind the convenience of purchasing airtime and internet bundles lies a commercial practice that deserves closer public scrutiny: the expiration of services customers have already paid for but have not fully consumed.

For example, a subscriber purchases 10GB of internet data, uses 6GB and expects the remaining 4GB to remain available. Instead, the unused balance may become inaccessible when the package expires.

The same concern applies to purchased call minutes and other prepaid services. The customer loses access to the remaining allocation, while the operator retains the payment already received.

This arrangement raises important questions about the relationship between commercial telecommunications policies and the rights of prepaid customers. It also brings the regulatory responsibilities of the Liberia Telecommunications Authority (LTA) into focus.

The controversy has gained national attention following an intervention by Grand Bassa County Senator Gbehzohngar Findley, who has called for a Senate investigation into the expiration of purchased data and call credits.

The legislative intervention presents an opportunity to examine whether existing telecommunications policies adequately protect consumers and whether Liberia needs stronger regulations governing unused prepaid services.

THE BUSINESS MODEL BEHIND EXPIRING DATA

Prepaid telecommunications services operate on a system in which customers pay in advance for a specified quantity of services.

Depending on the package, subscribers may purchase internet data, voice minutes, SMS messages or a combination of these services.

Operators attach validity periods to many of these packages, meaning that the purchased allocation remains available only within a specified period.

The commercial distinction is important: a customer is not necessarily purchasing unrestricted access to a specified quantity of internet data for as long as it remains unused. Rather, the customer is purchasing a defined package subject to its advertised terms and conditions.

However, the existence of contractual conditions does not automatically establish that those conditions are fair or consistent with consumer-protection obligations.

The central concern is the financial value of unused allocations. When a package expires before a customer consumes the entire allocation, the subscriber loses access to the remaining service.

This creates what can be described as an unused-bundle loss for consumers. The financial scale of this practice in Liberia, however, has not yet been independently established.

Neither the total volume of expired data nor the aggregate value of unused call credits should be assumed without obtaining records from the operators and the regulator.

That information is particularly important because the combined effect of relatively small losses across a large subscriber population could be substantial.

LIBERIA’S REGULATORY FRAMEWORK

The LTA is responsible for regulating telecommunications services and protecting consumers in Liberia.

Its Telecommunications Consumer Protection Regulations, adopted on November 22, 2024, establish obligations concerning transparency, disclosure of prices, service conditions and consumer complaints.

The regulations require service providers to give customers clear and understandable information about available services, applicable rates, terms, conditions and charges.

These obligations are directly relevant to prepaid bundle expiration because consumers must understand what they are purchasing, how long the service remains available and what happens to unused balances.

The regulations also establish mechanisms through which consumers can lodge complaints and seek redress where a provider is found to have violated applicable requirements.

However, an important legal distinction must be maintained: these provisions do not, by themselves, establish that every bundle-expiration condition is illegal. The legality of forfeiting unused balances must be assessed against the full regulations, applicable tariff orders, approved service terms and the operators’ contractual arrangements.

This is precisely why the LTA must explain the legal and regulatory basis for the practice.

HOW ARE TARIFFS AND BUNDLE CONDITIONS REGULATED?

The LTA is not merely an institution responsible for registering telecommunications companies. It has statutory responsibilities for regulating the sector and protecting consumers.

Under the Telecommunications Act of 2007, Section 42 provides for the filing and approval of tariffs applicable to service providers subject to tariff regulation, while Section 43 addresses the publication of tariff information.

The Act requires tariffs subject to LTA approval to receive that approval before taking effect.

This raises an important question: What is the actual regulatory status of the different data and voice bundles sold by Lonestar Cell MTN and Orange Liberia?

The public deserves access to the applicable tariff schedules, including the prices, data or voice allocations, validity periods and conditions attached to each package.

It is not enough for operators to advertise a bundle. Consumers should be able to establish whether its price and conditions have been properly disclosed and approved where required by law.

THE LTA’S OWN REGULATORY RECORD RAISES QUESTIONS

The regulator’s handling of telecommunications pricing also deserves examination.

In February 2019, the LTA issued Order 0016-02-25-19, establishing minimum price floors for on-net voice calls and mobile data services, alongside a regulatory fee.

However, the regulatory framework subsequently underwent changes.

In 2024, the LTA acknowledged that both Lonestar Cell MTN and Orange Liberia had continued offering voice and data services below the established price floors, despite penalties imposed on June 26, 2024.

The regulator subsequently issued Order 0012-09-23-2024, temporarily adjusting the relevant price-floor provisions while a cost study was undertaken.

The order raises questions about the regulator’s ability to balance competition, affordability and the commercial interests of telecommunications operators.

More recently, in October 2026, the LTA conducted a public consultation on proposed tariff guidelines intended to improve transparency in voice, SMS and data pricing, promotional offers, billing practices and the disclosure of service conditions.

The authority’s stated objective is to ensure that consumers understand the costs and conditions associated with telecommunications services.

But the public now needs to know whether these proposed guidelines will directly address the expiration of unused data and call credits.

THE ECONOMIC QUESTION: WHAT HAPPENS TO UNUSED BALANCES?

An equally important part of this investigation concerns the financial implications of expired bundles.

If subscribers collectively purchase millions of dollars’ worth of data and minutes but fail to consume all of them before expiration, the economic value of those unused balances deserves examination.

However, the actual amount retained by the operators cannot responsibly be established without access to their internal records.

The LTA should therefore require both companies to disclose, for an appropriate reporting period:

1. The total value of data bundles and call credits purchased.

2. The total value of unused data and minutes that expired.

3. The number of subscribers affected.

4. The volume of unused data and minutes forfeited.

5. The accounting treatment of expired balances.

6. Whether expired balances are recognized as revenue, deferred revenue or treated under another accounting arrangement.

Such information would help the public understand the financial dimensions of the practice without relying on speculation.

WHY CAN’T UNUSED DATA BE ROLLED OVER?

Telecommunications companies in different markets use various approaches to bundle validity. Some offer rollover arrangements, while others provide limited grace periods or allow balances to expire under disclosed conditions.

Liberia should not automatically assume that every international arrangement can be transferred without considering network capacity, costs, technical systems and commercial conditions.

Nevertheless, operators and the regulator should explain why consumers cannot be offered more flexible options.

Possible consumer-protection measures include:

– Automatic rollover of unused data when a subscriber purchases another qualifying bundle.

– A grace period before unused balances are forfeited.

– Separate treatment of promotional data and data purchased with customers’ own money.

– Clear notifications before bundles expire.

– Refund or credit arrangements where services cannot be delivered because of network failures.

– More flexible validity periods for customers purchasing larger bundles.

These proposals deserve public and regulatory consideration.

THE SENATE MUST GO BEYOND SUMMONING THE GSM COMPANIES

The Senate’s intervention presents an opportunity to establish a stronger consumer-protection framework.

The Committee on Posts and Telecommunications should obtain the actual tariff approval documents, consumer regulations, bundle terms and financial records from the operators.

It should also invite the LTA to explain whether the expiration of purchased data and call credits is expressly permitted under existing regulatory instruments.

The committee should distinguish between promotional benefits, free data, bonuses and services purchased directly with customers’ money.

It should further investigate whether subscribers receive sufficient notice before their bundles expire and whether operators provide accessible mechanisms for disputing incorrect deductions or lost balances.

Most importantly, the committee should determine whether existing law gives the LTA sufficient authority to require rollover, refunds or other remedies, or whether new legislation is necessary.

THE OPERATORS MUST ALSO BE HEARD

This investigation is not an attempt to portray Lonestar Cell MTN or Orange Liberia as guilty of wrongdoing before examining their explanations.

Both companies operate telecommunications infrastructure, invest in networks and provide services essential to Liberia’s economy.

They must, however, explain the commercial and technical reasons behind their bundle-validity policies.

The companies should also clarify whether customers are purchasing a defined quantity of data subject to a disclosed expiration condition or paying for temporary access to a specified service allocation.

Their responses are essential to a fair and balanced investigation.

THE CENTRAL QUESTION FOR LIBERIA

Telecommunications services have become an essential part of modern life. A mobile phone is no longer simply a device for making calls. It is a classroom, a business office, a banking channel, a source of information and a connection to the outside world.

For a student in a remote community, losing unused data could mean losing an opportunity to complete research. For a small business owner, it could mean repeatedly spending money on services that were not fully consumed.

For ordinary families already struggling with economic difficulties, every dollar matters.

Liberians should not have to accept commercial practices without understanding the legal and contractual conditions governing them.

The LTA must demonstrate that it is actively protecting consumers, while the Senate must ensure that the interests of ordinary subscribers are not overshadowed by the commercial interests of powerful service providers.

The question is not whether telecommunications companies should make profits. They have a legitimate right to operate commercially. The question is whether those profits should be made under transparent, fair and properly regulated conditions.

Until the regulator provides clear answers, the debate over expired data and call credits will remain an important test of consumer protection in Liberia.

SMART NEWS LIBERIA will continue examining the telecommunications sector in the public interest.

Investigation continues.

Lyndon J. Ponnie, Sr.
Lyndon J. Ponnie, Sr.
Liberian Investigative Journalist

Opinion Articles