spot_imgspot_img
Thursday, May 23, 2024

LIBERIA: RIGHTS COMMISSION RAISES CONCERNS OVER EXTRADITION OF ALLEGED SIERRA LEONEAN DISSIDENT WITHOUT DUE PROCESS

Date:

MONROVIA – Extraditing someone without due process is generally considered unlawful. Due process is a fundamental principle of law that guarantees fair treatment and safeguards the rights of individuals involved in legal proceedings. Extradition, the procedure for transferring a criminal suspect or convicted individual from one jurisdiction to another, usually entails intricate legal protocols. As Liberian Journalist, Lyndon J. Ponnie, reports, the National Human Rights Commission of Liberia has expressed dismay of how the Government of Liberia handled the extradition of alleged Sierra Leonean dissident, Mohammed Toure, otherwise called Yeate Yeate.

Toure was arrested Friday by Liberian Police at the request of President Julius Maada Bio of Sierra Leone. The Sierra Leonean government had accused the suspect and others of planning to overthrow the government.

Toure has been in Liberia since 2002 and according to the government of Sierra Leone, it is here in Liberia, that Toure allegedly coordinated the plot. They also said, he has been in Liberia and has been allegedly supported by a Liberian senator, Sarr Halie Joseph of Montserrado County.

The Sierra Leonean Government disclosed that the suspect has been seen in the convoy of the Montserrado County senator. It was based on intelligence gathered by Sierra Leone that it used Interpol to deliver a writ of arrest for Toure.

Interestingly though, while government prosecutors were starting to investigate the request, the  Liberian government issued a statement indicating they have decided to remove the suspect from Liberia. But the question is, did the government satisfy best practices and gave the suspect due process?

Different countries have their own laws and extradition treaties that govern the process of extradition. These laws and treaties often outline the specific requirements and procedures that must be followed to extradite an individual. Typically, an extradition request involves the submission of evidence and legal arguments to support the request, followed by a judicial review to determine whether the requested individual should be extradited.

Extradition without due process would violate the principles of fairness, human rights, and the rule of law. If an extradition process is conducted in violation of due process rights, it can be challenged in court, and the courts may refuse to grant the extradition request or order the release of the individual if they have already been extradited.

The recent arrest of Mohamed Toure, an alleged Sierra Leonean dissident, in Monrovia has sparked a contentious debate over whether the Liberian government should have ever extradited him to Sierra Leone in the first place without due process.

The chair of the National Human Rights Commission, Cllr. Dempster Browne thinks the Liberian Government did not meet the Minimum standard that resulted in Toure’s removal from the Country.

Cllr. Browne said Liberia has no extradition treaty with Sierra Leone. He further told newsmen at the Temple of Justice in Monrovia today that the Liberian government should have exercise caution and consider the principles of individual rights and national sovereignty before making a decision on Toure’s extradition.

It is crucial to examine the context of a previous extradition request made by Liberia and rejected by Sierra Leone, involving talk show host Henry Costa, to highlight the need for consistency and fairness in extradition cases,  Cllr. Browne said.

Preserving Individual Rights:

Extradition should not be treated as a mere administrative process but rather as a mechanism that directly impacts individuals’ fundamental rights. Mohamed Toure, like any other person, is entitled to due process and a fair trial.

Legal experts say the removal of Toure from Liberia means whatever evidence provided by Sierra Leone, means Toure was guilty of the allegations. That further gave credence to allegations by Sierra Leone that a Liberian Senator has been providing assistance to the suspect also correct.

The legal experts note that the Liberian government should have carefully evaluated the quality and credibility of the evidence presented by Sierra Leone, to ensure that it meets the necessary legal standards.

They point out that extradition should not be granted if there is a risk that Toure may face political persecution, human rights violations, or an unfair trial in Sierra Leone.

In the wisdom of Dempster Browne of the National Human Rights Commission, the allegations made against Toure are more political; and doubt whether he will ever get justice in Sierra Leone.

Consistency and Fairness:

The rejection of Liberia’s extradition request for Henry Costa by President Julius Maada Bio of Sierra Leone raises concerns about the principle of reciprocity in extradition cases, said Cllr Browne. “If President Bio refused to extradite Costa, based on his belief that Costa would not have received a fair trial in Liberia, it is only fair for Liberia to consider the same concerns in the case of Mohamed Toure.”

Upholding consistency and fairness in extradition matters is vital to maintaining diplomatic relations and fostering mutual trust between nations.

Respect for National Sovereignty:

“Extradition is ultimately a matter of national sovereignty. Each country has the right to decide whether to surrender an individual to another jurisdiction. Liberia should have exercised its sovereignty and carefully consider the potential implications of extraditing Toure to Sierra Leone”, said Browne.

First, another legal expert said that using Liberian soil to organize plots to overthrow a foreign power is against the laws of Liberia. The expert stated that if there was any evidence that Toure actually committed the crime, he should have first been tried under Liberia’s jurisprudence and sentenced.

Without sufficient evidence and guarantees of a fair trial, extraditing Toure could set a dangerous precedent where any country could demand the extradition of individuals based on political motivations rather than genuine criminal charges.

smartnews
Smart News Liberia is an online news outlet and a product of Smart Media Group Inc. Our website, smartnewsliberia.com, covers a broad spectrum of news content. For inquiries or information, you can reach us at 0777425285 or 0886946925, or email us at smartnewsliberia@gmail.com or info@smartnewsliberia.com.

LATEST DEVELOPMENT

LEADERSHIP IN QUESTION: EXPOSING GOVERNANCE FAILURES IN BOAKAI’S ADMINISTRATION

MONROVIA – Amara Konneh, former Finance Minister and current...

SENATOR AMARA KONNEH CRITICIZES UNITY PARTY-LED GOVERNMENT UNDER PRESIDENT JOSEPH BOAKAI

MONROVIA, LIBERIA – In a recent statement, Gbarpolu County...

URGENT ACTION NEEDED: ADDRESSING THE SEWAGE CRISIS IN CENTRAL MONROVIA

The ongoing issue of sewage leaking into the streets...

PRES. BOAKAI’S LEADERSHIP UNDER SCRUTINY AMID CENTRAL BANK OF LIBERIA CORRUPTION SCANDAL

The recent revelations of large-scale looting at the Central...

PRESIDENT BOAKAI’S PRIVATE JET USE EXPOSES HYPOCRISY

President Joseph Nyuma Boakai's use of a private jet...

LIBERIA NATIONAL UNIFICATION DAY: A CALL FOR UNITY AND PROGRESS

Today, May 14th, 2024, marks Liberia's National Unification Day,...

COMMENTARY

PRESIDENT BOAKAI ADDRESSES LOOMING RICE PRICE HIKE WITH KEY STAKEHOLDERS

In response to growing concerns regarding the potential surge...

 NATIONAL UNIFICATION DAY: REFLECTING ON LIBERIA’S JOURNEY TOWARDS UNITY

National Unification Day in Liberia, celebrated on May 14th,...

CELEBRATING WORLD PRESS FREEDOM DAY: THE PEN’S POWER TO ILLUMINATE AND EMPOWER

A Commentary By Socrates Smythe Saywon, Sr. May 3 marks...

COMMENTARY: SAMUEL P. JACKSON QUESTIONS BOAKAI ADMINISTRATION’S COMMITMENT TO CHANGE

In a compelling commentary, Development Consultant Samuel P. Jackson...

LATEST NEWS

CITIZENS ACCUSE STATE SECURITIES OF ACCORDING RULING PARTY PREFERENTIAL TREATMENT

MONROVIA – Several Liberians have accused state security apparatuses...

LIBERIA: REP GRAY, SPEAKER CHAMBERS OUSTED FROM THE LEGISLATURE

MONROVIA – Two long-serving members of the House of...

Share post:

EXCLUSIVE INTERVIEW

OPINION

THE PERILS OF PRAISE SINGING: HOW JOURNALISTIC INTEGRITY IS ESSENTIAL FOR ACCOUNTABILITY IN LIBERIA

Journalists play a crucial role in holding public officials...

AN OPINION: COMMENDING THE EMBASSY OF SWEDEN, SIDA, AND CENTAL FOR CHAMPIONING ANTI-CORRUPTION EFFORTS IN LIBERIA

An Opinion By Socrates Smythe Saywon The recent one-day Anti-corruption...

AN OPINION: ADDRESSING BRIDGE INTERNATIONAL ACADEMIES’ DEVASTATING IMPACT ON EDUCATION

An Opinion By Socrates Smythe Saywon The presence and operations...

THE GALLERY

spot_imgspot_img

MORE ARTICLES

spot_imgspot_img

MORE NEWS

LATEST DEVELOPMENT NEWS

LATEST CRIME NEWS

Share via
Copy link