MONROVIA, LIBERIA – Chief Justice Sie-A-Nyene Gyapay Yuoh today announced that the Supreme Court will issue a decision on the ongoing leadership conflict within the House of Representatives. She emphasized the Court’s role in upholding the Constitution while avoiding interference in the legislature’s internal affairs.
The dispute involves Speaker J. Fonati Koffa and the House’s majority bloc, represented by Cllr. Arthur Johnson and Cllr. Varney Sherman, respectively. Central to the case is whether the actions of the majority bloc, which has accused Speaker Koffa of corruption, undermining committee functions, and conflicts of interest, are constitutional. Speaker Koffa has denied these allegations, calling on his accusers to present their case through a formal resolution in session.
Cllr. Johnson argued before the Court that the majority bloc’s actions were unconstitutional, citing Articles 2 and 33 of the Liberian Constitution. He requested the Court to nullify their decisions, contending that the minority’s rights were being disregarded.
In contrast, Cllr. Sherman defended the majority bloc, asserting that their actions adhered to constitutional requirements. He argued that Speaker Koffa’s deputy rightfully assumed authority during his absence and that the majority acted appropriately when their concerns were overlooked upon the Speaker’s return. Sherman further emphasized that the dispute was political and urged the Court not to intervene.
The Ministry of Justice, represented by Solicitor General Cllr. Augustine C. Fayiah, echoed Sherman’s position, advising the Court to dismiss the case. According to the Ministry, the matter does not involve any constitutional violations and falls outside the Court’s jurisdiction, referencing relevant provisions of the Executive and Civil Procedure Laws.
The Supreme Court, after hearing arguments from both sides, reserved its ruling and temporarily suspended the case. Chief Justice Yuoh reiterated the judiciary’s focus on constitutional compliance while respecting the legislature’s independence.
This case highlights the tension between Speaker Koffa and the majority bloc, which claims to hold the support of 43 members compared to the Speaker’s 30. The allegations against Speaker Koffa include corruption and abuse of power—charges he has consistently denied.
